Is Staten Island the new Brooklyn?

by | Mar 16, 2017 | Development on Bay

Last June, CBS 2 reporter Elise Finch ran a story asking New Yorkers if Staten Island is turning into the “new Brooklyn” and shedding its reputation of being the “forgotten borough?”

Staten Island’s North Shore will be transformed once the $2-billion St. George Waterfront Redevelopment Project is complete in 2018. Millions of people are expected to visit the new attractions, especially the Empire Outlets and the New York Wheel.

In addition, the Lighthouse Point residence in Stapleton, offers the same living experience as Williamsburg or Hoboken, but with brand new buildings with a ton of amenities for much less money.

Borough President James Oddo said, “What we are historically is a bedroom community that in certain corridors will now be the home of a cool, hip, clean, safe diverse waterfront community.”

Some people interviewed are welcoming, and encourage people to move here because Staten Island is a good place to live, it’s homey and everyone knows each other. Brooklynites disagree, claiming Staten Island will never be as diverse as Brooklyn and should just be ourselves.

This story raises interesting and important questions about the heritage of and future identity of Staten Islanders.

Do we even want to become the new Brooklyn?

Agree? Disagree? Don’t care?

Let me know what you think.

Email me at

Amanda Gough

Written By Amanda Gough

Amanda is a freelance writer and photographer. She likes classic music, modern art, indie films and getting lost in new places. A Staten Island native, Amanda enjoys writing about her favorite local people, places and things.

Sponsored By:

Chez Vous Caterers Advertisement

Chez Vous Caterers and Party Rentals have been serving Staten Island elegant catering at inspiring prices for over 30 years.

Call 718-720-0900 and learn about how Chez Vous can make your next event one to remember!

For more information, Click here for great Staten Island Catering.

Like Us On Facebook

Support Your Local Writers

This Way on Bay is run by local writers and artists. Contribute to our mission by advertising. Packages start at $50.

Are you a local writer? Contact us to join the team!

Email for more info:

About This Way on Bay

Staten Island news, events, and visitor information. Online & print magazine focusing on the most important news, info, and events on Staten Island.

Learn More, here

Sponsored By:

Chez Vous Caterers Advertisement

NB Technologies has been helping Staten Island businesses find an audience on the web for 10+ years.

Offering internet marketing, social media management, and website design, our goal is to help clients make money and build the biggest business they can.

For more information, Click here