Pizza on Bay: Paulies Pizzeria & More

by | Dec 15, 2015 | Eat This Way on Bay


The North Shore of Staten Island is home of great pizza. Newcomer, Paulie’s Pizzeria, located at 500 Bay Street serves hot, delicious thin-crust pizzas, calzones, rolls, pasta dishes and will open Errigo’s their full service restaurant next door in the Spring.

We had a chance to chat with owner Phil Errigo and he spoke about how the restaurant only uses the freshest, highest quality ingredients and recipes, to prepare resulting in dishes that truly taste home-made. His top priorities are providing great food at reasonable prices and excellent service from a staff that makes you feel like family. They offer free delivery service and your food is guaranteed to arrive hot and fresh. They specialize in catering all occasions for any number of people.

Paulie’s Pizzeria | 500 Bay Street | website | where you eat


Other pizza joints on Bay Street & the surrounding area are listed by town:


Molo | 987 Bay St | where you eat

Pronto | 1077 Bay St | website

Rosebank Pizza | 1372 Bay St | where you eat

Tony’s Brick Oven | 1140 Bay St | website


Romeo’s | 117 Broad St | where you eat

Bari’s | 596 Bay St | website

St George

Pier 76 | 76 Bay St | website

Guisepes | 5 Hyatt St | where you eat

Christopher Olivieri
Written By Christopher Olivieri

Chris is a communications professional with a passion for pop culture, media, and all things creative. He has a Bachelor’s degree in Communications with a specialization in Media Studies and has experience in running a pop-culture website, freelance writing, coaching, and speaking engagements. He has worked behind the scenes on music albums and co-founded a boutique web design and marketing firm. He is also an amateur photographer and musician. He is always looking for the next exciting project to dive into.

Sponsored By:

Chez Vous Caterers Advertisement

Chez Vous Caterers and Party Rentals have been serving Staten Island elegant catering at inspiring prices for over 30 years.

Call 718-720-0900 and learn about how Chez Vous can make your next event one to remember!

For more information, Click here.

Like Us On Facebook

Support Your Local Writers

This Way on Bay is run by local writers and artists. Contribute to our mission by advertising. Packages start at $50.

Are you a local writer? Contact us to join the team!

Email for more info:

About This Way on Bay

Staten Island news, events, and visitor information. Online & print magazine focusing on the most important news, info, and events on Staten Island.

Learn More, here

Sponsored By:

Chez Vous Caterers Advertisement

NB Technologies has been helping Staten Island businesses find an audience on the web for 10+ years.

Offering internet marketing, social media management, and website design, our goal is to help clients make money and build the biggest business they can.

For more information, Click here